Letters: ICSD, rectify casting error

The actions we take define us. This is especially true when our youth is involved; they look to us as examples of how the world works and how to navigate it. Every action we take or decision we make or policy we put into practice tells them what our priorities and ethics as a society are.

In the current case of the casting of the part of Esmeralda in the Ithaca City School District production of the Hunchback of Notre Dame, it appears to be evident that the administration does not seem to care about making a culturally appropriate choice. I’m really quite shocked. Esmerelda is a Roma character, a woman of color; this has always been obvious. It is stated in the character description and also evident in the lyrics. And yet the casting of a white actor for this role is perplexing. I have read that the young woman cast is an actor of no mean talent and works hard to perfect her craft. This is highly commendable and I’m sure she would be outstanding in any other roles that she was appropriate for. In this case she is not appropriate; it is unfair students of color who auditioned for the role and it is unfair to put this young woman in this controversial position.

What’s important is the message that ICSD, in this decision, sends to its students, a decision that clearly says that they feel perfectly okay with denying a role meant for a person of color with no second thought. The only message I can take away from this is that ICSD has little interest in being an example of diversity to its student body. Ithaca students and parents will now see that the authority that runs their educational system thinks it’s okay to practice discrimination. Students of color will have one less set of authority figures to stand by their side and fight for their equality in the system. They will feel marginalized, disrespected, and of little worth. Discrimination is always a critical issue, but no more so than in the current political climate.

I have been a theatre professional for nearly 30 years, and I have seen some egregious examples of racially inappropriate casting. This incident ranks with some of the worst solely because of the damage it does to all of the young adults concerned, whether they be directly involved or spectators. ISCD must take steps to rectify this error. I strongly commend the students who have spoken up, who have stood against this injustice. This is what bravery truly is, and although their opinions may put them in the way of controversy, I urge them to stand by what they believe in. This is how things change for the better: by people facing injustice and fighting for their beliefs.

George Sapio,
Spencer